{ "status": "completed_two_simulators_against_independent_analytical_column_truth", "UTC": "2026-11-13T08:12:28.088577+00:00", "units": "ug/m2", "fixed_cells": 40, "intervals": 12, "all480_pairs_retained": true, "models": { "native_FLEX_vs_constantK_truth": { "pairs": 480, "RMSE_ug_m2": 0.9920811425569165, "MAE_ug_m2": 0.4711527481464817, "normalized_RMSE_by_truth_RMS": 0.00913161750677318, "NMB_percent": 0.26122221979465715, "maximum_absolute_error_ug_m2": 5.832156382631183, "mean_prediction_ug_m2": 48.136812858613936, "mean_truth_ug_m2": 48.011396423123045, "Pearson_r": 0.9999541939766738, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.6, "nonzero_union_count": 430, "both_zero_count": 50, "truth_positive_prediction_zero": 166 }, "CALMET_CALPUFF_vs_constantK_truth": { "pairs": 480, "RMSE_ug_m2": 40.40830085065103, "MAE_ug_m2": 15.468306429924377, "normalized_RMSE_by_truth_RMS": 0.37193847522970447, "NMB_percent": 14.479641307979136, "maximum_absolute_error_ug_m2": 204.2221040378081, "mean_prediction_ug_m2": 54.96327441214319, "mean_truth_ug_m2": 48.011396423123045, "Pearson_r": 0.9892635439208718, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.3697674418604651, "nonzero_union_count": 430, "both_zero_count": 50, "truth_positive_prediction_zero": 235 }, "CALPUFF_vs_own_Draxler_analytical_companion": { "pairs": 480, "RMSE_ug_m2": 0.9391038047708501, "MAE_ug_m2": 0.43828271569946914, "normalized_RMSE_by_truth_RMS": 0.0064916688830013725, "NMB_percent": -0.4259352972344147, "maximum_absolute_error_ug_m2": 11.956145781075065, "mean_prediction_ug_m2": 54.96327441214319, "mean_truth_ug_m2": 55.198383812302716, "Pearson_r": 0.9999773765642427, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.4588235294117647, "nonzero_union_count": 425, "both_zero_count": 55, "truth_positive_prediction_zero": 230 }, "Draxler_companion_vs_constantK_truth": { "pairs": 480, "RMSE_ug_m2": 40.4272189914859, "MAE_ug_m2": 15.2946472523864, "normalized_RMSE_by_truth_RMS": 0.3721126073834495, "NMB_percent": 14.969336292243943, "maximum_absolute_error_ug_m2": 205.56997000683975, "mean_prediction_ug_m2": 55.198383812302716, "mean_truth_ug_m2": 48.011396423123045, "Pearson_r": 0.9897202709199299, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.3697674418604651, "nonzero_union_count": 430, "both_zero_count": 50, "truth_positive_prediction_zero": 5 } }, "truth_validation": { "status": "independent_analytical_solution_evaluated_with_controlled_quadrature", "UTC": "2026-11-13T07:42:55.432952+00:00", "inputs_only_no_simulator_outputs": true, "physics": "Exact2D constant-K column advection-diffusion Green function; full3D solver column observable.", "point_kernel_formula": "Q/(4*pi*K*age)*exp(-((x-U*age)^2+y^2)/(4*K*age))", "finite_area_time_mean_formula": "Q/A/dt *integral0^tend (tend-max(tstart,age))*P_rect(age)dage", "source_Q_ug_s": 1000000.0, "U_m_s": 5.0, "K_m2_s": 50.0, "shape": [ 12, 40 ], "quad_rel_tolerance": 1e-10, "maximum_tightening_difference_ug_m2": 0.0, "maximum_reported_quad_vector_absolute_bound": 4.6150871351380614e-11, "steady_closed_Bessel_checks": [ { "x_m": 1000.0, "closed_Bessel_ug_m2": 562.7946565745806, "Green_integral_ug_m2": 562.7946565745806, "relative_difference": 0.0 }, { "x_m": 3000.0, "closed_Bessel_ug_m2": 325.4645730195351, "Green_integral_ug_m2": 325.46457301953495, "relative_difference": 5.239595050248017e-16 }, { "x_m": 5000.0, "closed_Bessel_ug_m2": 252.1873782527914, "Green_integral_ug_m2": 252.18737825279123, "relative_difference": 6.762045656840341e-16 }, { "x_m": 9000.0, "closed_Bessel_ug_m2": 188.01101988873992, "Green_integral_ug_m2": 188.01101988873992, "relative_difference": 0.0 }, { "x_m": 15000.0, "closed_Bessel_ug_m2": 145.64886340883223, "Green_integral_ug_m2": 145.64886340883214, "relative_difference": 5.854156791589593e-16 }, { "x_m": 21000.0, "closed_Bessel_ug_m2": 123.10161176124645, "Green_integral_ug_m2": 123.10161176124642, "relative_difference": 2.308800756039445e-16 }, { "x_m": 27000.0, "closed_Bessel_ug_m2": 108.56828661454944, "Green_integral_ug_m2": 108.56828661454936, "relative_difference": 6.544661962684773e-16 }, { "x_m": 33000.0, "closed_Bessel_ug_m2": 98.20536238984961, "Green_integral_ug_m2": 98.20536238984972, "relative_difference": 1.157643889855108e-15 } ], "CALPUFF_companion": "Predeclared Draxler Gaussian variance, not the targettruth. No simulator outputs used; source initialhorizontal sigma1m included as virtual age.", "Draxler_virtual_age_s": 1.2052279912359043, "vertical_GL8_initial_Gaussian_mass": 0.9988645254752467, "exact_mass_within_plusminus4sigma": 0.9999366575163338, "vertical_quadrature_relative_error": 0.0010721999568952827, "vertical_truncation_mass_fraction": 6.334248366623996e-05, "elapsed_seconds": 0.42908257899999924 }, "native_validation": { "status": "native_actual2h_fields_particle_regime_and_independent_mass_checked", "UTC": "2026-11-13T08:12:27.793478+00:00", "actualTimes": [ "20260101_001000", "20260101_002000", "20260101_003000", "20260101_004000", "20260101_005000", "20260101_010000", "20260101_011000", "20260101_012000", "20260101_013000", "20260101_014000", "20260101_015000", "20260101_020000" ], "fields": { "CONC": { "shape": [ 12, 1, 5, 4, 33, 73 ], "minimum": 0.0, "maximum": 80.30967712402344, "non_source_species_all_exact_ZERO": true }, "MIXINGRATIO": { "shape": [ 12, 1, 5, 4, 33, 73 ], "minimum": 0.0, "maximum": 55.36777877807617, "non_source_species_all_exact_ZERO": true }, "DRYDEP": { "status": "not_written_fill_values_because_deposition_is_disabled", "shape": [ 12, 1, 5, 33, 73 ], "not_replaced_by_fabricated_zeros": true }, "WETDEP": { "status": "not_written_fill_values_because_deposition_is_disabled", "shape": [ 12, 1, 5, 33, 73 ], "not_replaced_by_fabricated_zeros": true } }, "inventory": { "time_seconds": 7200, "count": 299999, "xy_coordinate_mode": 0, "mass_kg": [ 7.199975708974307, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "regime": { "height_min_m": 6000.0, "height_max_m": 6000.0, "PBL_min_m": 99.99998474121094, "PBL_max_m": 100.0000228881836, "tropopause_min_m": 10893.1240234375, "tropopause_max_m": 10893.126953125, "all_above_PBL": true, "all_below_tropopause": true }, "observed_diffusion_diagnostics": { "x": { "residual_mean_m": -7.5926742737579955, "K_second_moment_age_weighted_m2_s": 49.68542318201456, "standardized_mean": -0.011906065103978878, "standardized_second_moment": 0.9965052106993606, "normalized_fourth_moment": 2.979723561733888, "zero_age_particles_not_standardized": 208, "all_particles_retained_in_concentration_comparison": true }, "y": { "residual_mean_m": -4.907962805188517, "K_second_moment_age_weighted_m2_s": 50.07040147849529, "standardized_mean": -0.007283228210570167, "standardized_second_moment": 1.0017614531345602, "normalized_fourth_moment": 3.016071690070167, "zero_age_particles_not_standardized": 208, "all_particles_retained_in_concentration_comparison": true } }, "target_K_m2_s": 50.0, "expected_continuous_emission_kg": 7.2, "final_particle_mass_relative_error": -3.3737535684894325e-06, "output_scaled": false, "ledger_caveat": "Existing month ledger emission instrumentation is attached to the production stack/plume release path. This passive standard release uses uninstrumented emission: its emitted0/residual-7.1999757 entries are invalid as a closure test. Retained matches independent final particle inventory; mass checked directly against prescribed7.2kg, with all removal columns0. Original CSV retained unchanged.", "full3D_truth_claim": false, "physical_model_code_changes": 0, "columns_SHA256": "8484c2aa2c06dbc5aee0bb537d03328cd09c966d33906be168d212c2880092f6", "native_output_SHA256": "e1e88c4a1ac8318fb6e5659a5b55c6176643fa173784fd39a82c6aa6078c05da" }, "CALMET_validation": { "status": "actual_flat_CALMET_finite_uniform_wind_verified", "UTC": "2026-11-13T08:06:06.482819+00:00", "uniform_wind_PASS": true, "uniform_wind_tolerance_m_s": 0.001, "wind_max_abs_error_m_s": { "U": 4.8160552978515625e-05, "V": 4.749745494336821e-05, "W": 3.933907009923132e-06 }, "actual_intervals": [ [ 202600100, 0, 202600100, 600 ], [ 202600100, 600, 202600100, 1200 ], [ 202600100, 1200, 202600100, 1800 ], [ 202600100, 1800, 202600100, 2400 ], [ 202600100, 2400, 202600100, 3000 ], [ 202600100, 3000, 202600100, 3600 ], [ 202600101, 0, 202600101, 600 ], [ 202600101, 600, 202600101, 1200 ], [ 202600101, 1200, 202600101, 1800 ], [ 202600101, 1800, 202600101, 2400 ], [ 202600101, 2400, 202600101, 3000 ], [ 202600101, 3000, 202600101, 3600 ] ], "actual57_fields_finite": true, "field_ranges": { "U-LEV 1": [ 4.999999523162842, 5.000000476837158 ], "V-LEV 1": [ -9.596368727216031e-06, -9.596366908226628e-06 ], "WFACE 1": [ -9.536761602646493e-09, 9.536752720862296e-09 ], "U-LEV 2": [ 5.000014305114746, 5.0000152587890625 ], "V-LEV 2": [ 1.4901159374858253e-05, 1.490116301283706e-05 ], "WFACE 2": [ -4.76837556107057e-08, 4.768372718899627e-08 ], "U-LEV 3": [ 4.999977111816406, 4.999978065490723 ], "V-LEV 3": [ -2.2351743609760888e-05, -2.235173997178208e-05 ], "WFACE 3": [ -2.1934546623469942e-07, 2.336498852173463e-07 ], "U-LEV 4": [ 5.000047206878662, 5.0000481605529785 ], "V-LEV 4": [ 4.74974476674106e-05, 4.749745494336821e-05 ], "WFACE 4": [ -4.5776315005241486e-07, 4.386902503483725e-07 ], "U-LEV 5": [ 5.000047206878662, 5.0000481605529785 ], "V-LEV 5": [ 4.74974476674106e-05, 4.749745494336821e-05 ], "WFACE 5": [ -6.96180848080985e-07, 6.771088578716444e-07 ], "U-LEV 6": [ 4.999977111816406, 4.999978065490723 ], "V-LEV 6": [ -2.2351743609760888e-05, -2.235173997178208e-05 ], "WFACE 6": [ -8.869160978974833e-07, 8.678437097842107e-07 ], "U-LEV 7": [ 4.999977111816406, 4.999978065490723 ], "V-LEV 7": [ -2.2351743609760888e-05, -2.235173997178208e-05 ], "WFACE 7": [ -9.822837228057324e-07, 9.632111641622032e-07 ], "U-LEV 8": [ 4.999977111816406, 4.999978065490723 ], "V-LEV 8": [ -2.2351743609760888e-05, -2.235173997178208e-05 ], "WFACE 8": [ -1.1730189726222306e-06, 1.1539460729181883e-06 ], "U-LEV 9": [ 5.000047206878662, 5.0000481605529785 ], "V-LEV 9": [ 4.74974476674106e-05, 4.749745494336821e-05 ], "WFACE 9": [ -1.4114366422290914e-06, 1.3923646520197508e-06 ], "U-LEV 10": [ 5.000047206878662, 5.0000481605529785 ], "V-LEV 10": [ 4.74974476674106e-05, 4.749745494336821e-05 ], "WFACE 10": [ -2.3651073206565343e-06, 2.3460390821128385e-06 ], "U-LEV 11": [ 4.999988555908203, 4.9999895095825195 ], "V-LEV 11": [ -1.0710210517572705e-05, -1.0710208698583301e-05 ], "WFACE 11": [ -3.4570696243463317e-06, 3.1375900562125025e-06 ], "U-LEV 12": [ 5.000047206878662, 5.0000481605529785 ], "V-LEV 12": [ 4.74974476674106e-05, 4.749745494336821e-05 ], "WFACE 12": [ -3.933907009923132e-06, 3.6144272144156275e-06 ], "T-LEV 1": [ 288.1497497558594, 288.1502380371094 ], "T-LEV 2": [ 287.75994873046875, 287.760009765625 ], "T-LEV 3": [ 286.199951171875, 286.20001220703125 ], "T-LEV 4": [ 283.27496337890625, 283.2749938964844 ], "T-LEV 5": [ 280.02496337890625, 280.0249938964844 ], "T-LEV 6": [ 277.0999755859375, 277.0999755859375 ], "T-LEV 7": [ 275.14996337890625, 275.1499938964844 ], "T-LEV 8": [ 273.199951171875, 273.20001220703125 ], "T-LEV 9": [ 270.27496337890625, 270.2749938964844 ], "T-LEV 10": [ 262.14996337890625, 262.1499938964844 ], "T-LEV 11": [ 245.8999786376953, 245.89999389648438 ], "T-LEV 12": [ 232.8999786376953, 232.89999389648438 ], "IPGT": [ 4.0, 5.0 ], "USTAR": [ 0.34606167674064636, 0.3460617959499359 ], "ZI": [ 99.99991607666016, 100.00005340576172 ], "EL": [ 97.71331787109375, 97.7135238647461 ], "WSTAR": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "TEMPK": [ 288.1497497558594, 288.1502380371094 ], "RHO": [ 1.2252248525619507, 1.225226879119873 ], "QSW": [ 0.0, 46.5432243347168 ], "IRH": [ 49.0, 50.0 ] }, "synthetic_surface_SHA256": "a1ad2f1bb66d72cd80e9694c1097292dd7f3a56455534669f06bac9afa3ab321", "synthetic_upper_SHA256": "cba2fd216a4b7a02465f090f1762f65a909c25fee53331ed00d4af83dfcde26e", "actual_CALMET_SHA256": "5256db7b251815d0c77e6b6444104c55e22829163f4964613cb9096c6e076b6c" }, "inputs_not_tuned_to_concentration_results": true, "scope": "Horizontal advection and diffusion of the vertical-integrated column observable. Not full3D or mountain/source-buoyancy/deposition validation.", "CALPUFF_raw_concentration_units": [ "g/m3" ], "vertical_cubature_applied_without_renormalization": true, "calpuff_source_height_AGL_m": 6000.0, "source_mass_rate_kg_s": 0.001, "synthetic_prescribed_weather_not_observations": true, "official_CALPOST_summary_verified": true, "official_CALPOST_point_1hour_peak_ug_m3": 1.8264, "official_CALPOST_point_2hour_peak_ug_m3": 1.7896, "CALPUFF_mass_balance": { "emitted_kg": 7.2, "retained_kg": 7.2, "out_chemistry_dry_wet_all_zero": true, "original_massbal_SHA256": "2e07c635edcfa4f38c07611a20870785f9c6d6895dfcbca48d3309311a2dba65" } }