{ "status": "completed_independent_CALMET_CALPUFF_comparison_not_truth_validation", "UTC": "2026-11-13T06:39:25.095588+00:00", "reference_models": { "CALWRF": "2.0.3/190426", "CALMET": "6.4.0/121203", "CALPUFF": "6.42/110325", "CALPOST": "6.221/080724" }, "original_source_freeze_SHA256": "c223cd826d5a8dced68e829ea5967e05f4f179171d76f56a066d599f38f23883", "source_period_UTC": [ "2026-11-05T06:00:00Z", "2026-11-06T06:00:00Z" ], "sampled_cell_count": 197, "discrete_point_count": 5319, "hours": 24, "all_predeclared_pairs_retained": true, "all_pollutant_outputs_finite_nonnegative": true, "raw_binary_concentration_units": [ "g/m3 " ], "raw_binary_dry_units": [ "g/m2/s " ], "raw_binary_wet_units": [ "g/m2/s " ], "primary_metrics": { "pair_count": 4728, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 1.5877371135211684, "MAE": 0.2470371841275235, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.18853548354225208, "NMB_percent": 333.99709821430304, "mean_prediction": 0.2449837235270443, "mean_reference": 0.05644823998479225, "Pearson_r": 0.08129976747100048, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.2102081934184016, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 1489, "both_exact_zero_count": 716, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 2469, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 54, "normalized_mean_square_error": 182.2928170980441, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.0207229433373768, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.0780159521435693, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 4012, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 313 }, "daily_mean_metrics": { "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.5855700574894421, "MAE": 0.21757025653900822, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.18853548354225205, "NMB_percent": 333.99709821430304, "mean_prediction": 0.2449837235270443, "mean_reference": 0.05644823998479226, "Pearson_r": 0.23558668112838121, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.25165562913907286, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 151, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 46, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 24.79534104529732, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.29004332671381594, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.19289340101522842, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 38 }, "prediction_peak_within_sample": { "value_ug_m3": 69.5734634399414, "interval_h": [ 22, 23 ], "longitude": -122.94775390625, "latitude": 49.59077453613281, "group": 180, "native_ji": [ 85, 44 ] }, "reference_peak_within_sample": { "value_ug_m3": 7.903835276512955, "interval_h": [ 18, 19 ], "longitude": -122.89442443847656, "latitude": 49.50410842895508, "group": 130, "native_ji": [ 59, 60 ] }, "hourly_metrics": [ { "hour_start": 0, "hour_end": 1, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.19828927091146498, "MAE": 0.022535523705825684, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": -0.011227257754490403, "NMB_percent": -53.53772051586167, "mean_prediction": 0.009743485202644077, "mean_reference": 0.02097074295713448, "Pearson_r": 0.787527885709453, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.0, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 4, "both_exact_zero_count": 186, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 0, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 7, "normalized_mean_square_error": 192.4288945069776, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": 1.4038853715405526, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.0, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 11, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 0 }, { "hour_start": 1, "hour_end": 2, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.2822109036754559, "MAE": 0.054785301578598046, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.03203383459003577, "NMB_percent": 139.25238900807102, "mean_prediction": 0.05503798900219389, "mean_reference": 0.023004154412158126, "Pearson_r": 0.3808446305132923, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.1, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 10, "both_exact_zero_count": 170, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 4, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 13, "normalized_mean_square_error": 62.90407024581145, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": 0.9028669199399156, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.037037037037037035, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 27, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 1 }, { "hour_start": 2, "hour_end": 3, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.29384448067675745, "MAE": 0.07819120593327875, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.06715562439672874, "NMB_percent": 339.3561826223263, "mean_prediction": 0.08694475093563347, "mean_reference": 0.019789126538904724, "Pearson_r": 0.35492851632114475, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.38095238095238093, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 21, "both_exact_zero_count": 133, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 30, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 13, "normalized_mean_square_error": 50.18397776973011, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.22721558353266957, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.125, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 64, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 8 }, { "hour_start": 3, "hour_end": 4, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 1.0036036070015621, "MAE": 0.21274687721226623, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.18556388627852138, "NMB_percent": 899.9675485774094, "mean_prediction": 0.20618283932542233, "mean_reference": 0.020618953046900933, "Pearson_r": 0.0864463968142914, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.13333333333333333, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 30, "both_exact_zero_count": 83, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 75, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 9, "normalized_mean_square_error": 236.92195160965915, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.9362184392729247, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.03508771929824561, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 114, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 4 }, { "hour_start": 4, "hour_end": 5, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 1.9222424078944307, "MAE": 0.37597567881073696, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.3391774878076355, "NMB_percent": 1586.2645640437022, "mean_prediction": 0.36055963902603033, "mean_reference": 0.021382151218394804, "Pearson_r": -0.016991343908795708, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.05263157894736842, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 38, "both_exact_zero_count": 70, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 81, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 8, "normalized_mean_square_error": 479.27833921048335, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.880801132204662, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.015748031496062992, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 127, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 2 }, { "hour_start": 5, "hour_end": 6, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.7842815949008648, "MAE": 0.1784443484396332, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.16179008087860006, "NMB_percent": 1537.81713584348, "mean_prediction": 0.17231084287998455, "mean_reference": 0.010520762001384484, "Pearson_r": -0.022280783038586435, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.09259259259259259, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 54, "both_exact_zero_count": 48, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 91, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 4, "normalized_mean_square_error": 339.30030001001717, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.8326330246412308, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.03355704697986577, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 149, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 5 }, { "hour_start": 6, "hour_end": 7, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.5902457970052949, "MAE": 0.11904213584547613, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.0984507771178399, "NMB_percent": 581.0291371800644, "mean_prediction": 0.11539498366755882, "mean_reference": 0.01694420654971894, "Pearson_r": 0.04179771659616502, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.16363636363636364, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 55, "both_exact_zero_count": 24, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 118, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 178.17946051008082, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.0012548262089032, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.05202312138728324, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 173, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 9 }, { "hour_start": 7, "hour_end": 8, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.4731739581640543, "MAE": 0.1426070834788418, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.09235436188190613, "NMB_percent": 228.0339431665642, "mean_prediction": 0.1328546315345022, "mean_reference": 0.04050026965259605, "Pearson_r": 0.12733780743440362, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.1044776119402985, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 67, "both_exact_zero_count": 2, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 128, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 41.610894815592154, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.9321927334366551, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.035897435897435895, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 195, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 7 }, { "hour_start": 8, "hour_end": 9, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 1.2078695301474403, "MAE": 0.2378258753431803, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.1469643487811, "NMB_percent": 220.33520677645575, "mean_prediction": 0.21366469637021898, "mean_reference": 0.06670034758911898, "Pearson_r": 0.07716466716321602, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.125, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 72, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 125, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 102.37152775152123, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.9794973251063926, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.04568527918781726, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 9 }, { "hour_start": 9, "hour_end": 10, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.5818165423093971, "MAE": 0.15419755892217368, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.1293073504544109, "NMB_percent": 341.16872058359473, "mean_prediction": 0.16720864170796457, "mean_reference": 0.03790129125355366, "Pearson_r": 0.30037273386257063, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.26666666666666666, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 60, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 137, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 53.41452921229041, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.1173784485502665, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.08121827411167512, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 16 }, { "hour_start": 10, "hour_end": 11, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.689092260803509, "MAE": 0.20043151185923858, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.12695206497419018, "NMB_percent": 184.12045757133896, "mean_prediction": 0.19590261324501534, "mean_reference": 0.06895054827082514, "Pearson_r": 0.6541249540761023, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.18518518518518517, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 54, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 143, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 35.154165385332746, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.3406255572366323, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.050761421319796954, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 10 }, { "hour_start": 11, "hour_end": 12, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 1.0184810834406743, "MAE": 0.26830509305426903, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.1707023652446141, "NMB_percent": 161.55541908002272, "mean_prediction": 0.2763641661403554, "mean_reference": 0.10566180089574133, "Pearson_r": 0.5878153902069565, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.2535211267605634, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 71, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 126, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 35.522718540086736, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.26726836143581, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.09137055837563451, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 18 }, { "hour_start": 12, "hour_end": 13, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.8081873633172186, "MAE": 0.25227461576395915, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.17124309051374476, "NMB_percent": 164.2607070337017, "mean_prediction": 0.27549388402738184, "mean_reference": 0.10425079351363713, "Pearson_r": 0.5649266057064711, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.2826086956521739, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 92, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 105, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 22.742215994623667, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.1039996182415341, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.1319796954314721, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 26 }, { "hour_start": 13, "hour_end": 14, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.6975635134398916, "MAE": 0.19137966925710967, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.10172969077831223, "NMB_percent": 108.53360919268927, "mean_prediction": 0.19546074011410142, "mean_reference": 0.0937310493357892, "Pearson_r": 0.4005160158597753, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.21649484536082475, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 97, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 100, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 26.559781317937507, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.1936869679646807, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.1065989847715736, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 21 }, { "hour_start": 14, "hour_end": 15, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.8233563421279292, "MAE": 0.2611724240483493, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.16186140424509807, "NMB_percent": 150.91825868922086, "mean_prediction": 0.26911244573664606, "mean_reference": 0.10725104149154803, "Pearson_r": 0.19746058621849155, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.31521739130434784, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 92, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 105, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 23.487693382987356, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.9953850869814502, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.14720812182741116, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 29 }, { "hour_start": 15, "hour_end": 16, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.6227273088259673, "MAE": 0.2507126150026302, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.16118970165427096, "NMB_percent": 159.8684067153956, "mean_prediction": 0.2620161907436553, "mean_reference": 0.10082648908938437, "Pearson_r": 0.27866736247894547, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.2558139534883721, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 86, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 111, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 14.678884382710583, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.9551138228824879, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.1116751269035533, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 22 }, { "hour_start": 16, "hour_end": 17, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.6113819831922453, "MAE": 0.23991171961711824, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.14899212296241987, "NMB_percent": 153.31364816317839, "mean_prediction": 0.2461733750867194, "mean_reference": 0.09718125212429951, "Pearson_r": 0.19381106562617792, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.3253012048192771, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 83, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 114, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 15.62434076754806, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.9414910127979745, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.13705583756345177, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 27 }, { "hour_start": 17, "hour_end": 18, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.6188090975316332, "MAE": 0.21318054929057886, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.11535445449362067, "NMB_percent": 134.6376058242698, "mean_prediction": 0.20103219199303993, "mean_reference": 0.08567773749941923, "Pearson_r": 0.0994400464896891, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.27710843373493976, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 83, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 114, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 22.23206391121774, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.997952609324087, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.116751269035533, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 23 }, { "hour_start": 18, "hour_end": 19, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.8754834516111408, "MAE": 0.23274028960160312, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.12437581675225003, "NMB_percent": 171.9203993052657, "mean_prediction": 0.19672081900611615, "mean_reference": 0.07234500225386607, "Pearson_r": 0.007713070154221048, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.17567567567567569, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 74, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 123, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 53.856363380993926, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.0296139735320853, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.06598984771573604, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 13 }, { "hour_start": 19, "hour_end": 20, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.6485678100183961, "MAE": 0.21481985421404906, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.16098313408186338, "NMB_percent": 374.1650572016351, "mean_prediction": 0.2040077647851817, "mean_reference": 0.043024630703318356, "Pearson_r": 0.06878455229416436, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.19444444444444445, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 72, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 125, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 47.923323704607505, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.056181539984884, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.07106598984771574, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 14 }, { "hour_start": 20, "hour_end": 21, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.8022128789918955, "MAE": 0.2608465047148614, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.22580980531227382, "NMB_percent": 603.3296859227816, "mean_prediction": 0.2632370711307793, "mean_reference": 0.0374272658185055, "Pearson_r": 0.19864923075582952, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.10606060606060606, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 66, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 131, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 65.31968899989704, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.0586507198461526, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.03553299492385787, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 7 }, { "hour_start": 21, "hour_end": 22, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 3.719037424164549, "MAE": 0.5935387748426498, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.5582009234393366, "NMB_percent": 1200.2788651208546, "mean_prediction": 0.6047068596563449, "mean_reference": 0.046505936217008374, "Pearson_r": 0.03555174472973207, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.18571428571428572, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 70, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 127, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 491.8218402185913, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.0472437840060926, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.06598984771573604, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 13 }, { "hour_start": 22, "hour_end": 23, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 5.199585996064643, "MAE": 0.6903383159169265, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.6327851463501829, "NMB_percent": 1139.205557846302, "mean_prediction": 0.6883313242977764, "mean_reference": 0.055546177947593554, "Pearson_r": 0.00832631373498277, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.23943661971830985, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 71, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 126, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 707.1081062302989, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.0698162450948656, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.08629441624365482, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 17 }, { "hour_start": 23, "hour_end": 24, "pair_count": 197, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 2.3318478744892666, "MAE": 0.48288889260721135, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.4231013897795836, "NMB_percent": 728.9066887359463, "mean_prediction": 0.48114741903379676, "mean_reference": 0.05804602925421312, "Pearson_r": 0.0747090781067327, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.1791044776119403, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 67, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 130, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 194.69273766866633, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -1.2205678344047148, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.06091370558375635, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 197, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 12 } ], "fixed_receptor_cell_proxies": [ { "id": "R1", "name": "Outlet location", "native_ji": [ 45, 60 ], "actual_longitude": -122.89276123046875, "actual_latitude": 49.4591064453125, "comparison_group": 96, "scope": "Native nearest-cell proxy for original virtual receptor; not point exposure or an observation.", "prediction_ug_m3": [ 0.0, 0.00518828397616744, 1.2550972700119019, 1.208058476448059, 1.446510910987854, 0.24997852742671967, 0.3759162127971649, 0.37150850892066956, 1.1084094047546387, 0.6124556660652161, 0.5447548031806946, 0.6168880462646484, 0.4105919599533081, 0.0, 0.00021901838772464544, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.1387903094291687, 0.3241809904575348, 0.41516897082328796, 1.1324512958526611, 2.0897908210754395 ], "reference_ug_m3": [ 0.0, 0.1973896743980505, 0.5343021486208467, 0.0925501770511558, 0.011531400047457594, 0.00899100406738425, 0.0010121708664780074, 1.4478424427237433, 3.33614594254599, 0.525274682285339, 0.43785218388593267, 0.6830369983546433, 0.43703478865654605, 0.1794392468467284, 0.13257364395854776, 0.10726354873723688, 0.08684854575968519, 0.06937322507944634, 0.044930084179910595, 0.02761350417459755, 0.034007112270837775, 0.04188984015447163, 0.05267702896044758, 0.08284395746694978 ], "metrics": { "pair_count": 24, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.8090449804373163, "MAE": 0.506320081820299, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.15556400523835137, "NMB_percent": 43.552866824346125, "mean_prediction": 0.5127483115338691, "mean_reference": 0.35718430629551773, "Pearson_r": 0.21995954937256365, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.2222222222222222, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 18, "both_exact_zero_count": 1, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 5, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 3.573952100504912, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": 0.03171043963811338, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.17391304347826086, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 23, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 4 }, "prediction_peak_interval_h": [ 23, 24 ], "reference_peak_interval_h": [ 8, 9 ] }, { "id": "R2", "name": "5 km north", "native_ji": [ 59, 60 ], "actual_longitude": -122.89276123046875, "actual_latitude": 49.50406276937136, "comparison_group": 130, "scope": "Native nearest-cell proxy for original virtual receptor; not point exposure or an observation.", "prediction_ug_m3": [ 0.3011014759540558, 0.9514815211296082, 0.10310004651546478, 0.00016541164950467646, 0.01720982976257801, 0.0, 0.0, 0.9669371247291565, 1.6262611150741577, 2.330548048019409, 1.4560860395431519, 0.9369903802871704, 0.014763941988348961, 0.10665053129196167, 0.035576023161411285, 0.007818344049155712, 0.026627400889992714, 0.04110197722911835, 0.07280921936035156, 0.16205468773841858, 0.09650621563196182, 0.5506852865219116, 0.31552329659461975, 0.0930280014872551 ], "reference_ug_m3": [ 0.9544783472673448, 0.46398980732664197, 0.005495843993888576, 0.000552281563160333, 7.688453123871241e-07, 3.093158540127216e-06, 0.7728556046112162, 1.5521003065857792, 0.025421990604987486, 0.11981348263348238, 0.18661674525335137, 0.2472622728228124, 0.7867322476070001, 1.7938623971535093, 5.180624174295846, 2.9803827232997193, 3.0282720469357614, 4.682216537580376, 7.903835276512955, 2.404371086075196, 0.7805229157623871, 1.127465058608318, 1.4827766466185965, 0.47261807646437026 ], "metrics": { "pair_count": 24, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 2.4925854427752263, "MAE": 1.6452248312780797, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": -1.1141351588738246, "NMB_percent": -72.36157347628257, "mean_prediction": 0.4255427466086985, "mean_reference": 1.5396779054825231, "Pearson_r": -0.341162313336887, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.045454545454545456, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 22, "both_exact_zero_count": 0, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 2, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 9.482591426297358, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.6598706567156976, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.041666666666666664, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 24, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 1 }, "prediction_peak_interval_h": [ 9, 10 ], "reference_peak_interval_h": [ 18, 19 ] }, { "id": "R3", "name": "10 km north", "native_ji": [ 72, 60 ], "actual_longitude": -122.89276123046875, "actual_latitude": 49.5490187422324, "comparison_group": 155, "scope": "Native nearest-cell proxy for original virtual receptor; not point exposure or an observation.", "prediction_ug_m3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 4.532661478151567e-06, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.06480520963668823, 0.26914605498313904, 0.26159489154815674, 1.6934701204299927, 1.4101871252059937, 0.4538125693798065, 0.3159310221672058, 0.4333500564098358, 0.6598317623138428, 0.6861873865127563, 0.5908322930335999, 0.10895492136478424, 0.2394411563873291 ], "reference_ug_m3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 1.6326320908090034e-05, 0.00019607120860894368, 0.0006998819135693605, 0.005571643843139124, 0.06188028633261308, 0.11266552395798388, 0.15741411467718308, 0.2568485340354787, 0.3299786138270211, 0.4186016637517142, 0.5786668522682425, 0.4114727969050802, 0.1286982731743239, 0.20066156837099894, 0.24460495034735172, 0.25041408890878863, 0.1612264735642284, 0.19363846406834007 ], "metrics": { "pair_count": 24, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.38215863437062725, "MAE": 0.18550321842045056, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.15309554060662647, "NMB_percent": 104.58369220006664, "mean_prediction": 0.2994812125847754, "mean_reference": 0.14638567197814892, "Pearson_r": 0.6880538478443857, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.5384615384615384, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 13, "both_exact_zero_count": 5, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 5, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 1, "normalized_mean_square_error": 3.3313418380397724, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.12292509974584045, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.3684210526315789, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 19, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 7 }, "prediction_peak_interval_h": [ 14, 15 ], "reference_peak_interval_h": [ 16, 17 ] }, { "id": "R4", "name": "15 km NNW", "native_ji": [ 85, 44 ], "actual_longitude": -122.94645470200342, "actual_latitude": 49.58936646565974, "comparison_group": 180, "scope": "Native nearest-cell proxy for original virtual receptor; not point exposure or an observation.", "prediction_ug_m3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0070836832746863365, 0.341911256313324, 1.2350295782089233, 0.9112927913665771, 0.656534731388092, 0.5134963989257812, 0.4495934844017029, 0.41661524772644043, 12.433345794677734, 69.5734634399414, 20.06515884399414 ], "reference_ug_m3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 1.4494901924395271e-06, 5.533506742879779e-05, 0.0004226255379608586, 0.0007201935596244404, 0.018576630006552335, 0.027552584915933903, 0.047319189411802846, 0.07333286520140578, 0.09681275407136125, 0.11248566763915004, 0.09778991520526248, 0.059085758837058924, 0.031962457668220805, 0.017931081250811817, 0.015562050320537008, 0.03173584379773848, 0.034392188135341936, 0.026871726592395187 ], "metrics": { "pair_count": 24, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 14.991582367113176, "MAE": 4.426362888055936, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 4.4129547888962515, "NMB_percent": 15291.558958692525, "mean_prediction": 4.441813552092451, "mean_reference": 0.02885876319619914, "Pearson_r": 0.04923356742059023, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.0, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 11, "both_exact_zero_count": 6, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 7, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 1753.3027382424723, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": 0.10380667077342659, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.0, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 18, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 0 }, "prediction_peak_interval_h": [ 22, 23 ], "reference_peak_interval_h": [ 15, 16 ] }, { "id": "R5", "name": "5 km east", "native_ji": [ 45, 81 ], "actual_longitude": -122.82379278207817, "actual_latitude": 49.45908588304936, "comparison_group": 97, "scope": "Native nearest-cell proxy for original virtual receptor; not point exposure or an observation.", "prediction_ug_m3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.014186890795826912, 0.0, 0.0, 0.14798936247825623, 0.46917977929115295, 0.4065941572189331, 0.10655216127634048, 0.034186817705631256, 0.0037358265835791826, 0.0023598468396812677, 0.0, 0.01321095135062933, 0.01919277384877205, 0.02242652140557766, 0.1745888739824295, 0.3672757148742676 ], "reference_ug_m3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.05263647337777859, 0.056971992467378225, 0.01038079952496229, 0.0013290065351378455, 0.0009055014512552954, 0.004868006918768913, 0.01522964231132554, 0.07900518150135077, 0.1984042270880431, 0.3221828784069173, 0.1936613908652131, 0.11337385864686039, 0.09960538386955264, 0.08688923242359976, 0.07279249738506922, 0.05562771019675513, 0.03918837060618226, 0.026170014424370745, 0.02624880862461616, 0.029052862002463316, 0.03408681840979857, 0.11021193504904396 ], "metrics": { "pair_count": 24, "units": "ug/m3", "RMSE": 0.11938061830905297, "MAE": 0.07474356308502815, "mean_bias_prediction_minus_reference": 0.0063607118985264345, "NMB_percent": 9.372235276346952, "mean_prediction": 0.07422831990212823, "mean_reference": 0.0678676080036018, "Pearson_r": 0.5017424538311366, "FAC2_both_positive": 0.38461538461538464, "FAC2_both_positive_count": 13, "both_exact_zero_count": 2, "prediction_zero_reference_positive": 9, "reference_zero_prediction_positive": 0, "normalized_mean_square_error": 2.8290164600479395, "mean_fractional_bias_nonzero": -0.9136646174992508, "FAC2_nonzero_union": 0.22727272727272727, "FAC2_nonzero_union_count": 22, "FAC2_in_factor_two_count": 5 }, "prediction_peak_interval_h": [ 12, 13 ], "reference_peak_interval_h": [ 11, 12 ] } ], "preprocessing_wind_change": { "RMSE_m_s": 1.0577484132813681, "mean_difference_m_s": 0.49906074009427237, "max_absolute_m_s": 3.62008325492189, "CALMET_mean_m_s": 3.1731241469235973, "WRF_mean_m_s": 2.6740634068293248 }, "limitations": [ "CALPUFF is an independent guideline-recommended model, not an analytical solution or observed truth. No permit-compliance claim.", "Artificial seed42 terrain has no corresponding monitoring truth; source uses historical annual-rate priors and frozen forecast forcing.", "Both models share WRF-compatible weather. CALMET adjusts winds, surface fluxes and mixing heights; concentration differences combine preprocessing, plume-rise, turbulence, deposition and sampling differences.", "CALWRF applied its original range QC to12 negative cloud-water traces; raw weather was not changed. This reference transform is disclosed.", "CALPUFF500m diagnostic grid samples existing terrain information; it does not generate new terrain detail, building wakes or resolved small eddies.", "197 fixed cells and quadrature only; reported sampled peaks are not the full-domain peak. Five virtual receptors are compared using their nearest native cells.", "Native particle bin/CIC and CALPUFF point-puff operators differ;3x3x3 quadrature approximates terrain-following0..20m volume support.", "No calibration, concentration scaling, threshold alteration or agreement-based mask selection. Unit conversions only.", "24 hours are a research case, not a multi-year BC regulatory assessment. Independent observation validation remains unavailable.", "CALPUFF transport domain112.5x112km is inscribed in the child weather grid; original FLEX can use the larger parent meteorology. Boundary exits/re-entry differ and are not isolated as a solver error." ], "source_inputs_SHA256": "8f28043932e849ce3d05a75ead329c5aed6c14a147ca3d8a97258e8d20d6aff4", "calpuff_con_SHA256": "3dc4f97900c00a6cae0e20c1f29e08feb652142e3b10b1d41b8935ec3837c4f1", "analysis_seconds": 0.18978238299999894, "deposition_comparison": { "status": "not_evaluated_no_ground_flux_receptors", "reason": "All CALPUFF quadrature nodes are elevated0..20m. Zero receptor deposition flux there is not a surface flux comparison or evidence of no deposition.", "prediction_mean_dry_ug_m2": 33.071081472471654, "prediction_mean_wet_ug_m2": 13.572163416350515, "reference_mean_dry_ug_m2": null, "reference_mean_wet_ug_m2": null }, "official_CALPOST_summary_verified": true }